Skip to content
(647) 692-7243info@newhouseandassociates.co
6 min readBy Matt Newhouse, MAccBookkeepingGrowth

Have I outgrown my bookkeeper, and what does moving actually involve?

Outgrowing an arrangement that used to work is a size change, not a complaint about anybody. How to tell which one you have, when to move, and what you need to take with you.

This question usually gets asked quietly, and usually by somebody who feels slightly disloyal for asking it. It is worth getting the framing right first, because it changes the answer: the common situation is not that anybody has done anything wrong. It is that the business grew and the arrangement did not.

Outgrowing a setup is not a complaint about anyone

A business doing forty transactions a month needs somebody careful entering them and reconciling the bank. That is a real job, done well or badly, and the right answer for that stage. The same business at four hundred transactions a month, with staff, a credit facility and a landlord who wants statements, needs something structurally different: a close that runs to a date, reporting somebody can make a decision from, and more than one person who knows how the file works.

Those are not the same job with more hours in it. So the question is not whether the person doing your books is good. It is whether the shape of the arrangement still matches the shape of the business.

What it looks like when the arrangement has been outgrown

  • The numbers arrive late enough to be history. If September's figures land in November, they are a record rather than information, and no decision was ever made with them.
  • You cannot get a figure explained. Not a complaint about tone: a specific number on a specific report, and no one can say what is in it.
  • The year end file needs rebuilding before a return can be prepared from it, and the cost of that lands on your tax bill rather than your bookkeeping bill.
  • The bank feed is imported but nothing is reconciled, so the closing balance in the books has never been tied to a statement.
  • The account that tracks money moving between you and the company has not been explained in two years.
  • Everything depends on one person. A holiday, an illness or a resignation stops your books entirely, and nobody else knows the coding.
  • Sales tax returns are filed on figures the books do not support, which is the most expensive item on this list.
  • Nobody has told you anything you did not already know in the last twelve months.

When the problem is not the bookkeeping at all

Worth being honest about, because moving will not fix any of these and the same frustration will reappear in six months with a new name on it.

  • The receipts and invoices are not reaching anybody. No one can code a transaction they have no document for, and the gap in the books is a gap in the paperwork.
  • The chart of accounts was never set up for the business you now run, so the reports group things in a way that cannot answer your questions.
  • You are getting a bookkeeping output and wanting a reporting one. Those are two different pieces of work, and the second was probably never asked for or quoted.
  • The software is wrong for the operation, which is common where a platform runs the operational side and the accounting file was never designed to receive it.

When to move

The clean break is a year end. One complete year sits with one provider, the file is closed, and nothing has to be stitched together afterwards. Which is why this gets asked in November and December: the opportunity is in front of people.

The next best is a month end with the sales tax period closed behind it. Mid-period is possible and is done regularly, but it means one year with a seam in the middle of it, and the seam is where the duplicated and missing entries live.

What is worth avoiding is moving during the three weeks when a return is being prepared. Everybody involved is busy, the file is in motion, and questions take a week to get answered.

What you have to get out, and what you actually own

This is the part that decides whether a switch is smooth or awful, and almost nobody is told about it beforehand.

  1. The accounting file itself, with the full transaction history rather than an opening balance. A file that starts at a single number has thrown away every detail behind it.
  2. Who the software subscription actually belongs to. See the note below, because this is the one that bites.
  3. Bank and credit card statements for the whole period, from the bank rather than from the file.
  4. Payroll records and the remittance confirmations, which are what a slip has to agree with.
  5. Every sales tax return filed, with its confirmation number.
  6. The adjusting entries from the last year end, which live with whoever prepared the return and are what makes the opening balances correct.
  7. The source documents: receipts, bills, contracts, finance agreements.
  8. A written list of the recurring jobs and their dates, because some of them are somebody's habit rather than anything written down.

The access to tidy up on the way through

A switch is also the one natural moment to audit who can see and do what, which on most small businesses has never been reviewed since the day each person was added.

  • Representative access on your CRA business account: add the new authorisation, and remove the one that is no longer needed rather than leaving it in place.
  • Bank access, which should be read-only for anybody doing the books and should never have been anything more.
  • Administrator rights on the payroll platform.
  • Ownership of the accounting file, as above.

What a clean handover looks like

One date, agreed in writing. One last month closed and signed off by the outgoing arrangement. A list of what is open and unresolved at that date, rather than a silence that gets discovered in March. Nothing left depending on an individual's memory or on an account nobody can log into.

Done that way, the receiving side can start from a known position. Done badly, the first job is working out where the books actually stand, which is a real piece of work and is being paid for either way.

How a takeover runs here

The first step is a look at where the file genuinely stands: what is reconciled, what period is actually closed, what is open. That comes before any quote, because quoting a monthly fee against a file nobody has opened is guessing, and the guess is always corrected upward later.

If there is a gap between the last closed month and today, that is a defined catch-up project with its own fixed scope, separate from the ongoing work, so you can see what is the backlog and what is the running cost. From there it is the monthly close, the reconciliations and the year end file. We file GST/HST from your own books and simple personal returns; corporate, trust and partnership returns are done by our associated CPA. If you already have an accountant you intend to keep, nothing about this changes that: the books get prepared to the standard they ask for and the file goes to them.

And if the honest answer after that look is that the arrangement you have is fine and the problem is a chart of accounts or a missing pile of receipts, that is worth hearing before you move rather than after.

Want a second set of eyes on your numbers?

A free 20-minute consultation, no obligation.