Skip to content
(647) 692-7243info@newhouseandassociates.co
4 min readBy Matt Newhouse, MAccBookkeepingTax

Is once-a-year bookkeeping a good idea?

Doing a whole year in one go is legal, common, and for some businesses completely fine. Here is how to tell which kind you are, without anybody selling you anything.

A lot of businesses hand over a box or a folder once a year, somebody turns it into a return, and that is the whole arrangement. It is legal, it is common, and for a certain kind of business it is the right answer. It is worth knowing which kind, because the question is usually settled by habit rather than by arithmetic.

When once a year genuinely is enough

There is a real set of businesses where monthly bookkeeping would be spending money to produce information nobody needs.

  • A sole proprietor with one income stream, no staff, no stock and no borrowing.
  • A business whose decisions do not depend on the numbers: the work arrives, the price is fixed, and nothing about how you run the week would change if you knew last month's margin.
  • A holding company, or a company that is dormant.
  • A business small enough to be under the sales tax registration threshold and not voluntarily registered.

If you are reading that list and nodding, the honest advice is to keep your receipts somewhere findable and carry on. Nobody needs to sell you a monthly service.

What it actually costs when it is not enough

The cost is almost never the bookkeeping fee. It is four other things, and none of them show up as a line item.

A year of decisions made without numbers

If the books are done in May for the year that ended in December, every pricing decision, every hire and every purchase in those seventeen months was made on a feel. Some of those were right. The ones that were wrong stayed wrong for a year, because nothing was measuring them.

Sales tax filed on numbers nobody has checked

This is the expensive one, and it is specific to Canadian businesses that are registered. If you file GST/HST during the year and the books are not written up until after the year ends, those returns were filed on figures the books had not yet confirmed. When the books catch up and disagree, the correction is yours to make, and the amount involved is money you collected on the CRA's behalf rather than money you earned.

A more expensive year end than you were expecting

Twelve months of unsorted records take longer to work through than twelve months of closed ones, and the work happens at the busiest time of the year for everybody qualified to do it. The same file, handed over reconciled, is a smaller job. You are paying for the same work either way; the difference is whether you are also paying for the reconstruction.

Nothing to show anybody who asks

Lenders, landlords, insurers and buyers all ask for recent statements, and all of them ask on their own timetable rather than yours. A business whose most recent numbers are from last December cannot answer in March, and the answer is usually needed in the week it is asked for.

The middle option almost nobody is offered

The choice is not annual or monthly. Quarterly bookkeeping exists, costs a fraction of monthly, and fixes most of what is wrong with annual: the sales tax returns get filed on checked numbers, nothing has to be reconstructed from memory, and you see the business four times a year instead of once.

For a business with staff or stock, monthly earns its fee. For a lot of the businesses currently doing it once a year, quarterly is the honest recommendation and it is rarely the one being made, because it is the smaller sale.

If you are already behind

Then this is not the question in front of you, and the answer to the one that is, is that catching up is a defined project with an end rather than an open bill. That is covered separately, and the thing that decides the cost is not how far behind you are.

What we would do

We do monthly and quarterly bookkeeping, and we file GST/HST from your own books and simple personal returns. Corporate, trust and partnership returns are done by our associated CPA. If what you want is a return once a year and nothing else, we are not the cheapest way to get one, and saying so is more useful than pretending otherwise.

Want a second set of eyes on your numbers?

A free 20-minute consultation, no obligation.