Chair rent, commission or employee?
Three ways to pay the people in your salon, three completely different sets of books, and three different sets of obligations. One of them is reassessed more often than the other two put together, and the cost lands on the salon.
The three arrangements, and what each one means
These are genuinely different businesses, not three ways of describing the same one. The revenue on your books, the obligations you carry and the risk you hold all change depending on which you are actually running.
Chair rental
Your revenue is the rent. Their service income is not yours at all, which makes your gross revenue much smaller and your margin on it much higher. No source deductions, no vacation pay, no termination obligations. Rent is a commercial supply, so it counts toward your taxable supplies whatever your service revenue does.
Commission
Paying a percentage rather than an hourly rate does not by itself make somebody a contractor. If you set the prices, the hours and the standards, a commission stylist is generally an employee who is paid by commission, with all the deductions and obligations that carries.
Employee
Hourly or salaried, source deductions withheld and remitted, vacation pay and the rest. More administration and more cost, and the one arrangement nobody comes back and reassesses. For many salons the real comparison is this against chair rental, with commission sitting closer to this than owners expect.
Why chair rental is the one that gets looked at
Because the paperwork and the day-to-day usually disagree, and only one of them counts.
A genuine rental is a stylist running their own business out of your premises. Their clients, their prices, their hours, their products, their booking, their risk of an empty day. If the salon sets the price list, publishes the schedule, takes the bookings through its own system, supplies the colour and requires a uniform, then whatever the agreement is called, the working relationship looks like employment and that is what gets weighed.
The cost lands on the salon
If the relationship is reassessed as employment, the obligation to have withheld and remitted was the salon’s, going back over the period, with the employer portions, interest and penalties. The stylist does not get that bill. That is the asymmetry worth knowing about before somebody else raises it, and it is the same test applied in every industry: what decides contractor or employee.
What a salon’s books should separate
Four revenue streams with four different margins, and most salons run them through one account and then wonder why the numbers do not tell them anything.
- Service revenue, which is the business you think you are in.
- Chair rent, if you let chairs, which is property income with a different margin entirely.
- Retail product sales, which carry stock, shelf space and shrinkage, and often earn far less than they appear to.
- Tips, handled according to whether the salon controls them, and visible rather than netted off.
Separated, you can answer which chair earns, whether the retail line is worth the floor space and what your actual service margin is after product cost. Combined, you have a number that goes up and down for reasons nobody can name. The rest of the sector detail, including card settlement against the deposit and handling cash properly, is on the shops and salons service page.
Questions salon owners ask
Is renting a chair the same as having a contractor?
Not automatically, and that is the whole problem. A genuine chair rental is a stylist running their own business out of your premises: their own clients, their own prices, their own hours, their own products, their own booking. If you set the prices, the schedule and the standards, supply the products and take the booking, calling it chair rental does not make it one.
What happens if a chair rental gets reassessed as employment?
The obligation to have withheld and remitted was the salon's obligation, so the salon can be liable for the amounts that should have been withheld and remitted, including the employer portions, with interest and penalties, going back over the period. The stylist is not the one who gets the bill. That asymmetry is why this is worth looking at before somebody else does.
How should chair rent be recorded?
As rental revenue to the salon, separately from service revenue, because they are different businesses with different margins and mixing them makes both unreadable. The stylist's own service income is not the salon's revenue at all under a true rental, which is the single biggest difference in how the books look.
Is chair rent subject to GST/HST?
Renting space to a business is a commercial supply and the usual rules apply to it, which catches owners who assumed that because they are under the threshold on service revenue they are under it overall. The test looks at total taxable supplies, and rent counts toward that.
What about tips?
How tips are handled depends on whether they are controlled by the salon or go directly to the stylist, and that distinction drives whether they attract source deductions. Tips processed through the salon's card terminal and redistributed are usually a different matter from cash left in a hand. Either way, money moving through the business account needs to be visible in the books rather than netted off.
Does retail product revenue change anything?
It is a separate revenue stream with a completely different margin and it should sit in its own account. Many salons discover their product line is roughly breaking even once the shelf space and the unsold stock are counted honestly, which is a decision worth making on numbers rather than on habit.
Not sure which arrangement you are actually running?
Send us how your stylists are paid and what your books currently show. We will tell you what they would need to separate, in writing, at no cost.