Hiring somebody to do your books is hard to judge from the outside, because the thing you are buying is accuracy and you cannot inspect accuracy in a sales conversation. What you can do is ask questions whose answers are checkable, and notice which ones get a straight answer.
These are the nine worth asking. Ask them of us too. The last section is our own answers, so you can see what we think a good one sounds like.
First, work out which of three things you need
The words get used loosely and it causes most of the confusion. A bookkeeper records what happened and keeps the accounts reconciled. A tax preparer turns that into a return. A licensed CPA firm is the only one that can issue an audit, a review or a compilation report, which is what a bank or a regulator sometimes asks for by name.
Plenty of arrangements combine the first two. Almost nobody needs the third until somebody specifically asks for it. Knowing which you are shopping for stops you paying for a tier above what the situation needs, and stops you discovering in April that the arrangement cannot produce what a lender wants.
What does closed mean to you?
The single most useful question on this page, because the phrase "the books are done" covers everything from every account tied to a statement, with the odd items raised, to transactions imported and roughly categorised.
A good answer names reconciliation against the statement rather than against the bank feed, and says what gets produced at the end of it. An answer that stays at "we keep everything up to date" has not answered.
Who does the work, and who do I talk to?
These are allowed to be different people and often should be. What matters is that both have names and that you know which one answers an email about a figure. The answer to avoid is the one where you cannot establish who touches the file.
What happens when that person is away?
A one-person arrangement is not a problem in itself, and a lot of excellent bookkeeping is done by one person. The question is whether anything exists if they are ill for three weeks in February: a documented process, somebody who can step in, access that is not in one person's head.
What do you need from me, and by when?
Books fall behind more often because documents did not arrive than because anybody stopped working. A good answer is specific and dated: these things, by this day of the month, in this form. An arrangement with no stated expectation of you is one where the gap gets discovered in the spring.
What does the year end file look like when you hand it over?
Worth asking even if the same people also do the return, because it is the question that separates recording from finishing. A good answer describes a file with no open questions in it: balances tied to statements from outside the business, unusual items noted, the things that need a decision listed rather than buried.
Who files my corporate return, and are they licensed to?
A direct question with a direct answer, and the answer should be a name. Plenty of good arrangements involve a bookkeeping firm doing the books and a licensed CPA doing the return, which is a structure rather than a shortcoming. What you want to avoid is not finding out which arrangement you are in.
Whose name is the software subscription in?
If the accounting software is billed to whoever does your books rather than to your business, the file can leave when they do. Ask at the start, when it takes ten minutes to put in your own name, rather than at the end, when it has become a negotiation.
How is the fee set, and what makes it change?
Any basis can be fair. What matters is that it is stated, and that you know which event triggers a new number: a volume band, a new entity, payroll going from four people to fourteen. A fee with no stated trigger is a fee that gets revisited at a moment you did not choose.
What is not included?
Ask it in exactly those words. Everybody has an answer and the answer is the scope. Catch-up work, the corporate return, payroll, sales tax registration and anything a regulator asks for by name are the usual ones, and finding out now is free.
Our own answers
Closed means every account reconciled to the statement, nothing left in a suspense account, and a monthly set of statements with the unusual items flagged. The work is done by a named person on our team and you can reach them directly; the firm is more than one person, so a holiday does not stop your books. We tell you what we need and by which day of the month, in writing, at the start.
We do the bookkeeping, the financial operations and the year end file, and we file GST/HST from your own books and simple personal returns. Corporate, trust and partnership returns are done by our associated CPA, and US federal and state returns by our associated US CPA in your state. We are not a CPA firm and we do not issue audit, review or compilation reports; those are licensed engagements that belong with a CPA firm, and when you need one we introduce you and prepare the books it works from.
The fee is set by transaction volume, agreed before any work starts, and fixed until your business changes in a way we name in advance. There is an engagement letter and it says all of this. And we look at the file before quoting, because quoting against a file nobody has opened is the thing that produces the number you get told about later.